Not Everyone Mourns the Queen. For Many, She Can’t Be Separated from Colonial RuleCurrent Event Close Reading and Critical Thinking Questions for Social Studies Teachers
The following Social Studies event discussion is based on the original news article Not Everyone Mourns the Queen. For Many, She Can’t Be Separated from Colonial Rule, published September 12, 2022, by Juliana Kim, NPR. The article reports on how Queen Elizabeth II’s death has garnered a spectrum of feelings around the world about her life, legacy, and the monarchy - particularly with respect to British colonial rule in Africa and elsewhere during her reign. Below you will find the article and some critical thinking questions to pose to your Social Studies students.
Queen Elizabeth II’s death has garnered a spectrum of feelings around the world about her life, legacy, and the monarchy.
When she took the throne in 1952, more than a quarter of the world’s population was under British imperial power. That was more than 700 million people—including in parts of Africa, Asia, the Middle East and the Pacific islands.
While her 70-year reign saw the British Empire become the Commonwealth of Nations—and the decline of the United Kingdom’s global influence—the scars of colonialism linger. Many note the enslavement, violence and theft that defined imperial rule, and they find it difficult to separate the individual from the institution and its history.
Moses Ochonu, a professor of African studies at Vanderbilt University, told NPR the queen’s death brought attention to “unfinished colonial business.”
“There is a sense in which Britain has never fully accounted for its crimes,” Ochonu said.
Elizabeth was associated with colonial and de-colonized Britain
The memory of Elizabeth is complicated by the fact that during her rule, more than 20 countries gained independence, Ochonu said.
“It’s her dual status as the face of colonialism, but also a symbol of decolonization that defines how she is perceived in many former British African colonies.”
Ochonu’s own feelings toward the queen’s death are mixed—in part because of his childhood. He was born in Nigeria, a little over a decade after the country saw an end to colonial rule.
He recalled how the queen continued to be fondly associated with prestige and grandeur. Images of Elizabeth as a young woman visiting parts of Africa humanized the crown and the monarch.
But coupled with that nostalgia is “residual anger” over the brutal price paid for many countries’ independence. Ochonu said in Nigeria, many are still haunted by Britain’s role in their civil war, when the global power secretly tried to prevent the Republic of Biafra’s secession efforts. In Kenya, Britain tortured thousands of rebels in detention camps, for which it apologized in 2013.
That’s why Ochonu said her death prompts a time of reflection rather than mourning.
Elizabeth was a symbol of Britain’s denial for colonial crimes
Others find it difficult to celebrate the queen’s life—in part because they feel she should be held accountable for what her country did.
“We essentially have to respect her for her very long service, but as the monarch, she cannot be disentangled from colonization of South Asia,” Mou Banerjee, a professor of South Asian history at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, told NPR.
Banerjee is from India, which gained independence from Britain in 1947. Although Elizabeth was crowned five years later, Banerjee said many Indians hoped the queen would express remorse for the damages of colonialism.
That was the case in 1997 during what would be the queen’s last visit to India. Elizabeth told Indians “history cannot be rewritten” in reference to the 1919 massacre in Jallianwala Bagh, where hundreds of Indians were shot and killed by British troops.
Those sentiments have resurfaced as many wonder what will happen to the queen’s crown jewel following her death. During colonial times, India was forced to hand over the 105-carat Kohinoor diamond to Britain. Many are also calling for the return of the Cullinan diamond back to South Africa.
“The jewels represent a history of coercion, subjugation, loot, loss, grief,” Banerjee said.
Similarly, the queen’s death has also reminded many people of the lack of reparations to former colonies.
Opal Palmer Adisa, the former director of the Institute for Gender and Development Studies at the University of the West Indies, told All Things Considered Britain has yet to even apologize to the African diaspora.
Over 2.2 million enslaved people were taken to British colonies in the Caribbean.
Palmer Adisa said in Jamaica, children were not taught specifics about what happened under British rule—even when discussing slavery.
“The implications and the horrendous actions of the British... were never delineated,” she said.
Many people are wondering why the British monarchy still exists
For some, the queen’s death has reignited conversations around the purpose and place for a monarch today.
Banerjee has been skeptical of the crown from a young age, when she would hear her grandparents’ anecdotes of the Bengal famine of 1943, where at least 3 million people died of starvation as a result of Britain’s overseas economic policies.
Although Elizabeth’s eldest son now sits on the throne, Banerjee believes this can still be a time of reckoning over the institution.
“They say, the sun never sets on the British Empire. I think it has set with the death of Queen Elizabeth,” Banerjee said.
“It is time that we come to terms with that history of enslavement, that history of colonization.”
Critical Thinking Questions
- The first section of an article should answer the questions “Who?” “What?” “When?” and “Where?” Identify the four W’s of this article. NOTE: The rest of the article provides details on the why and/or how.
- Does this article have any bias? Why or why not?
- Who was Queen Elizabeth II? When did she take the throne and how long did she rule?
- What percentage of the global population was under Elizabeth’s rule? About how many people was that?
- Which regions outside of Europe were under her rule?
- What is colonialism? What is imperialism? Define each term in your own words.
- How many countries were decolonized and gained independence during Elizabeth’s rule?
- Explain the following phrase: “The sun never sets on the British Empire.” What does it mean?
- Using examples from the article, why might some people find it difficult to mourn Elizabeth’s death?
- Do you think monarchy is a relevant form of government in today’s world? Why or why not?
Resource of the Week
The following recommended Social Studies classroom item is available at teachersdiscovery.com.
Forms of Government and Economic Ideologies Posters
Elizabeth II was queen, but do your students know the difference between a constitutional monarchy and a monarchy?
Help them understand with 12 clearly and concisely defined forms of government and economic ideologies.